Pistols at Fort Sumter: Alfred Moore Rhett, the Fatal Duel, and the Siege of Charleston

      Lieutenant Alfred Moore Rhett c. 1861

Colonel Alfred Moore Rhett was an aristocratic South Carolina planter, a notorious duelist, and the controversial Confederate commander of Fort Sumter.

Born on October 18, 1829, in Beaufort, South Carolina, Alfred Moore Rhett was raised in the heart of the antebellum Southern aristocracy.  He was the son of Robert Barnwell Rhett, a prominent political figure known as the "Father of Secession" for his fiery radical activism.  Growing up in an environment dominated by extreme state-rights ideology, young Rhett was conditioned to adopt the elite pride, strict codes of honor, and aggressive temperament that defined the plantation gentry.  His early education was tailored to prepare him for a life among South Carolina's political and social elite.

                  Robert Barnwell Rhett 

Following his preparatory schooling, Rhett attended Harvard University, graduating in the Class of 1850.  His time in Cambridge was marked by personal friction and lavish spending.  Letters from his father complained that Alfred spent excessively on fashionable clothing and rapidly exhausted his annual allowances.  Despite these clashes over his wild spending habits, he completed his studies and returned to South Carolina.

Upon his return home, Rhett assumed the life of a wealthy rice planter in the Colleton District of South Carolina.  Managing large agricultural holdings, he fully integrated into the economic and social circles of lowcountry plantation owners.  During this decade, Rhett developed a reputation for being fiercely proud, arrogant, and extremely quick to take offense, traits that would later dominate his military career.

When South Carolina seceded and the Civil War erupted in 1861, Rhett immediately entered military service as a First Lieutenant in the 1st South Carolina Artillery.  He participated in the initial bombardment of Fort Sumter in April of 1861 and quickly rose through the officer ranks due to his social standing and administrative competence, advancing to Major by early 1862.

                       John C. Calhoun 

Personal animosity between Major Rhett and his commander, Colonel William Ransom Calhoun, nephew of John C. Calhoun, reached a boiling point in September of 1862.  Rhett deeply resented Calhoun's West Point education and commanding authority, frequently denouncing him in public and calling him derogatory names while intoxicated.  Calhoun challenged Rhett to a duel to defend his honor, which took place near Charleston on September 5, 1862.

The fatal duel with Colonel Calhoun was fought under strict and deadly conditions. Calhoun preferred shooting on the "rise" while Rhett favored the "drop," but Rhett waived his preference and agreed to Calhoun's terms.  Both men fired within an instant of each other.  Calhoun's shot missed, but Rhett's bullet struck him square in the torso, and he died a short time later.  Rhett was initially arrested for illegal dueling, but General P.G.T. Beauregard, desperate for artillery commanders, pardoned Rhett and promoted him to Colonel to fill the very vacancy his bullet had created.

As commander of Fort Sumter from 1863 onward, Rhett oversaw its defense during relentless Federal naval bombardments. Under his command, the garrison endured immense fire from Federal ironclads and siege batteries, holding the fortress even as its brick walls were reduced to rubble.  Known as an uncompromising disciplinarian, Rhett maintained a harsh reputation in the ranks.  He was reported to have boasted of executing deserters and using hounds to track down conscripts hiding in the swamps.

               Colonel Alfred Moore Rhett 

When Confederate forces evacuated Charleston in February of 1865, Rhett was assigned to command an infantry brigade during the retreat through the Carolinas. Shortly before the Battle of Averasboro in March of 1865, Rhett rode too close to his own skirmish line and was captured by Federal scouts.  Taken before General William T. Sherman, Rhett maintained a haughty, unrepentant demeanor.  Federal officers noted his aristocratic defiance, one Federal soldier is documented as having called him a "devil in human shape."  He was sent north and imprisoned at Fort Delaware until his release in July of 1865.

After the war, Rhett returned to a ruined South Carolina and re-entered public life in Charleston.  He served as Chief of Police for the city of Charleston, where his iron-fisted leadership style reemerged during Reconstruction tensions.  He later served as a State Constable and Trial Justice, and is reported to have used force to help quell political unrest during Reconstruction.

            Alfred Moore Rhett later in life

Rhett spent his final years combining local civic duties with attempts to revive his rural agricultural interests.  He contracted a severe case of malaria while managing rice planting operations in the country during the summer of 1889.  Complications set in, and Rhett died of a "congestive chill" in Charleston on November 12, 1889, at the age of 60.  He was buried in the historic Magnolia Cemetery in Charleston, South Carolina.

              Grave of Alfred Moore Rhett 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The North Carolina Monument at Appomattox

Holding the Line at Kettle Run: How Ewell’s Tactical Rearguard Stalled Hooker and Paved the Way to Second Manassas.

The Fanny Affair: North Carolina's First Naval Victory 165 Years Ago Today