Duty & Honor: Major Robert Anderson: Standing Firm in the Harbor of Decision


Major Robert Anderson is best remembered as the resolute Union commander of Fort Sumter whose steadfast refusal to capitulate to Secessionist demands sparked the American Civil War. 

Born on June 14, 1805, at his family’s plantation, "Soldier's Retreat," near Louisville, Kentucky, Anderson grew up steeped in Southern heritage and military tradition.  His father, Richard Clough Anderson, was a Revolutionary War veteran, slaveholder, and Virginia lands agent, while his mother belonged to the prominent Marshall family of Virginia.  This upper-class Upper South upbringing deeply shaped his early worldview and political sensibilities.  

Anderson is my 3rd cousin 6x removed.   We are related to his father's grandmother through the Overton family of Virginia.  

​Following his family's martial legacy, Anderson entered the United States Military Academy at West Point in 1820 and graduated in 1825.  Over the next several decades, he established himself as a highly capable and methodical artillery officer.  He served with distinction in the Black Hawk War, where he famously mustered a young volunteer named Abraham Lincoln into service, as well as the Second Seminole War and the Mexican-American War.  Seriously wounded at the Battle of Molino del Rey in 1847, Anderson earned a reputation for quiet bravery and deep institutional loyalty to the U.S. Army.  

                   Anderson and family

​Beyond his military service, Anderson’s personal ties to the South strengthened considerably during the antebellum era.  In 1842, he married Elizabeth Bayard Clinch, the daughter of General Duncan Lamont Clinch, a wealthy Georgia rice planter and slaveholder.  Through his wife's inheritance, Anderson temporarily became a slaveowner himself, though he later sold those enslaved individuals prior to the outbreak of the Civil War.  Politically, Anderson openly sympathized with Southern grievances regarding states' rights, strongly desiring to avoid any armed conflict between the regions.  

The First Gun at Fort Sumter, oil on canvas by        Alban Jasper Conant, c. 1861.

​In November of 1860, as sectional crises reached a boiling point following the election of Abraham Lincoln, Secretary of War John B. Floyd assigned Major Anderson to command the Federal forts guarding Charleston Harbor, South Carolina.  The James Buchanan administration deliberately selected Anderson because of his known Southern sympathies and familial connections.  The administration believed a Southern-born officer who sympathized with the region's culture would act with tact, exercise restraint, and avoid provoking local Secessionists into open conflict.  

​Upon taking command at Fort Moultrie, Anderson found his position tactically undefendable against a potential land assault from South Carolina militia.  Despite his personal sympathies for the South and his anguish over the impending dissolution of the Union, Anderson placed his military duty and constitutional oath above his political inclinations.  

         Anderson raising the flag at Sumter

On the night of December 26, 1860, six days after South Carolina seceded, Anderson executed a covert, tactical transfer of his small two-company garrison from vulnerable Fort Moultrie to the unfinished brick fortress of Fort Sumter in the middle of the harbor.  

​This bold tactical movement outraged South Carolina authorities and embarrassed the Buchanan administration, effectively thwarting Southern plans to easily seize the harbor defenses.  For nearly four months, Anderson and his men remained isolated at Fort Sumter, facing severe supply shortages and mounting pressure from the newly formed Confederate government.  Throughout the intense standoff, Anderson managed to maintain a remarkable level of diplomacy and dignity, desperate to avoid firing the first shot of a civil war.  

                      33-star Storm Flag

​The standoff culminated on April 12, 1861, when Confederate forces under General P.G.T. Beauregard, who had formerly been Anderson's student at West Point, opened fire on Fort Sumter.  Anderson’s garrison endured 34 hours of heavy bombardment before surrendering on honorable terms on April 13th.  He evacuated his men north, taking the fort's battered 33-star flag with him.  Though he lost the fort, Anderson became an instant national hero in the North for his steadfast defense of Federal authority.  Promoted to Brigadier General, he was assigned to command Federal forces in his home state of Kentucky to help keep the border state in the Union fold.  

             Fort Sumter's surrender flag

​The intense physical strain and emotional turmoil of the siege, coupled with the anguish of fighting against the South he loved, shattered Anderson's health, forcing him to step down from active command in late 1861.  He officially retired from the U.S. Army in 1863.  

         Anderson’s telegraph confirming Fort                              Sumter's surrender 

On April 14, 1865, four years to the day after surrendering Fort Sumter, a restored Anderson returned to Charleston to personally raise the same shell-torn flag back over the fort.  Seeking relief for his declining health, Anderson lived out his final years in Europe and died in Nice, France, on October 26, 1871, before being laid to rest at West Point.  

                 Grave of Robert Anderson 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The North Carolina Monument at Appomattox

Holding the Line at Kettle Run: How Ewell’s Tactical Rearguard Stalled Hooker and Paved the Way to Second Manassas.

The Fanny Affair: North Carolina's First Naval Victory 165 Years Ago Today